To grasp Marcel Sternberger's impact on photography, it's essential to explore the history that molded his early life. Sternberger, who was born in the Austro-Hungarian Empire—a state that lasted until World War I's end—witnessed constant change and disruption. Raised in Budapest within a close Jewish family, his childhood was steeped in intellectual pursuit, enriched by his culturally vibrant surroundings. These dual facts would lead to his desire to capture and preserve the faces and moments of both great men and women of the 20th century and every day people.
Transitioning to adulthood, Sternberger served as an intelligence officer in World War I. This sharpening of his espionage and signals intelligence skills was a precursor to his journalistic career. The war's conclusion marked the collapse of the Austro-Hungarian Empire, transforming Sternberger's identity to that of a Hungarian citizen, amid a country redefining its borders and political identity.
The post-war period in Hungary was fraught with political volatility. The brief ascendancy of a communist regime under Bela Kun in 1919, characterized by a declared "dictatorship of the proletariat," plunged Hungary into chaos, disproportionately affecting the Jewish community and intellectuals. Sternberger's family, navigating these perilous times, managed to avoid persecution due to Sternberger's military background and keeping a low profile.
The collapse of communism in Hungary led not to stability, but to the rise of fascism. This helped trigger national conflicts and foreign interventions by Czechoslovakia, Yugoslavia, and Romania. The subsequent civil unrest further imperiled the Jewish community. Hungary's shift to a constitutional monarchy under Miklos Horthy ushered in a wave of conservative nationalism and intensified antisemitism.
Hungarian Prime Minister Imre Nagy, C. 1950
During this period, Sternberger faced the widespread issue of educational quotas at the University of Budapest, mirroring the antisemitic sentiments prevalent even in Western nations like the United States. Interestingly, it was Sternberger's artistic achievements and endorsements from influential figures like the Belgian Royal Family and Joseph Kennedy, the Ambassador to the Court of St. James, that likely secured his entry into the U.S. during an era of restrictive immigration policies.
Sternberger's resilience against oppressive forces was clear through his activism. With other Jewish war veterans, he led a protest against the Horthy regime's antisemitic policies. This brave defiance forced him to flee Hungary to avoid backlash. His flight to Paris marked the start of his exile. It was an odyssey that took him through over ten countries, equipped him with fourteen languages, and had him confronting the ongoing challenge of antisemitism that he had first faced in his birthplace.
In the United States, Sternberger's work reflected his deep concerns for Hungary's political direction. At a time when the Soviet Union sought to shift its neighbors' allegiances, Sternberger wrote a poignant essay on the critical episode of Ferenc Nagy's forced resignation as Prime Minister. Sternberger's analysis casts a somber light on this juncture, perceiving it as a definitive close to a chapter in modern history, marking a moment when "a region of Europe has been withdrawn from the community of Western nations." Sternberger saw this event not just as a local political disturbance but as a symptom of a larger issue: the failure to limit Soviet expansion, which put the effectiveness of the Yalta Agreement into question.
At the heart of Sternberger's case was a poignant quote from Nagy, who mourned the erosion of freedom— a principle he championed as "the purest humanitarian idea and one which represents the only way to the prosperity of the oppressed classes." Sternberger used this quote to underscore Nagy's deep-rooted commitment to democratic principles, dismissing any attempts to label him as reactionary, which the photographer deemed “obviously preposterous."
Sternberger then examined the factors leading to Nagy's political demise. He attributed it to his democratic stance and quest for Western alliance for Hungary. He detailed Nagy's triumph in the United States, where he secured the return of substantial gold reserves; this bolstered Hungary's economy with the introduction of a new currency, supported by U.S. financial aid. It was Nagy's "western orientation" that Sternberger identifies as the crux of his undoing, a stance intolerable to Soviet ambitions in Hungary.
Sternberger shed light on a deliberate Moscow-led campaign aimed against any Western inclinations—be they ‘political, economic, or cultural.’ He pointed out the active role of Soviet propaganda. This drive to influence Hungarian thought was evidenced by numerous articles in newspapers that criticized Western values. These values included ironically press freedom, and sought to undermine Hungary's historical cultural ties with Western Europe.
Through his analysis, Sternberger identified the efforts to weaken Hungary's Western connections in favor of Eastern European alignments as part of a broader Soviet agenda to shift Hungary and it populace's sensibilities towards the East. Recent developments in Europe's political and military climate, as evidenced by the war in the Ukraine and other issues, have seen a resurgence of similar strategies. Russia, after a period of relative inactivity, appears to be engaging with these tactics with renewed vigor.
Much of Sternberger’s work centered around photographing the political and cultural elite, both in Europe, America, and elsewhere. In this instance, Sternberger’s writings offer a powerful critique of what he saw as threats to the freedoms and cultural identity of Hungary. His essay stands as a testament to his steadfast commitment and advocacy for Hungary’s cause. Though penned from afar, his words are rooted in a deep-seated connection to his country of origin, despite his persecution.
His insights into the socio-political shifts of his time remain relevant, echoing the timeless struggle for national identity in the face of external pressures. Through Sternberger’s eyes, we gain a clearer understanding of how cultural and political tides can shape a nation's path and the spirit of its people. His advocacy continues to inspire and educate, underlining the power of the human voice against the currents of history.
Subscribe to receive Sternberger Collection news and updates.
Your personal information will not be shared with third parties.